How the polls might be wrong (again) this year

The World News Papers


It just seems to keep on happening — Democrats get their hopes up from rosy-looking polls, but they get a rude awakening when votes are tallied on election night.

In 2016, Trump’s win shocked the world. In 2020, a seeming Democratic romp turned into a nail-biter. And now, as the 2022 midterms are drawing nearer, polls show Democrats performing surprisingly decently — pointing toward a close election rather than the long-expected GOP wave.

Unless, of course, the polls are just underestimating Republicans again.

And lately, there’s been a debate among election analysts, including the New York Times’s Nate Cohn and FiveThirtyEight’s Nate Silver, about whether that’s exactly what we should expect this time.

It has always been a good idea to treat polls, poll averages, and election forecasts with some healthy skepticism. They’re all good at getting us in the neighborhood of the outcome, most of the time. But in any given cycle polls are frequently off by a few points on average, and they can miss by much more in individual races while being on target in others.

So sure, polls can be wrong. The debate here is over a different question: Have polls so persistently underestimated Republican candidates of late that it’s simple common sense to suspect it’s happening again?

Or is the recent polling error tougher to generalize about, meaning that we should be more hesitant to suspect a bias against the GOP, and that Democrats maybe shouldn’t feel so anxious?

My own view is that it makes all the sense in the world to be deeply skeptical of polls showing big Democratic leads in states like Wisconsin and Ohio, where polls have consistently greatly overestimated Democrats across several election cycles. But the picture is less clear in other states, where polling error hasn’t been so clear or consistent. I wouldn’t blindly “trust” those polls, but I wouldn’t assume they’re likely wrong, either.

What was wrong with the polls?

The last cycle in which Democrats really felt the polls didn’t set them up for disappointment was 2012. Polls that year did fluctuate somewhat, but they usually showed President Obama as the favorite to win reelection, and forecast models based on those polls did the same.

There was, however, a dissenter — Dean Chambers, founder of the website “Unskewed Polls.” Chambers, a conservative, argued that most pollsters were systematically undercounting Republican voters. So he re-weighted their results to reflect the more-Romney-leaning electorate he expected — “unskewing them.”

Much mockery from liberals about this rather crude methodology ensued, and when the results of the election came in, Chambers got egg on his face — Obama and Democrats actually did somewhat better than the polls had showed.

Here’s the funny part: In every election cycle since then, Chambers would have had a point.

Andrew Prokop / Vox

First came the 2014 midterms, a GOP wave year. The final Senate polls correctly indicated a Republican takeover, but they understated the size of GOP victories in almost every competitive race, by nearly 6 points on average. National House polling showed a similar discrepancy.

In 2016, it happened again. National presidential and House polls were fairly close to the results, but in most presidential swing states, polls underestimated Trump. Polls also underestimated GOP Senate candidates in competitive contests by about 3 points on average.

See also  Runway teases AI-powered text-to-video editing using written prompts

In the 2018 midterms, then, there was another discrepancy between national House polling (which was fairly close to accurate) and competitive Senate state polling (where Republicans were underestimated by 2.5 points on average).

And in 2020, polls had their worst performance in decades, because they significantly overestimated Democrats’ margins at nearly every level — presidential popular vote, presidential swing states, Senate swing states, and the House — by an average of nearly 5 points.

So, over the last four cycles, national polls have twice been reasonably accurate and twice underestimated Republicans. But relevant for our purposes this year, polls of competitive Senate races underestimated Republicans in all four election cycles. (And, of course, presidential swing state polls underestimated Trump twice, though that’s more relevant for 2024.)

Why were the polls off?

A polling error of about 3 points on average is actually pretty normal. All polling is an inexact science attempting to model the opinion of a large population based on a sample of a small part of that population. Things could go awry in sampling (if certain voters are more difficult for the pollster to reach), or in weighting (as pollsters try to ensure their sample is representative of the electorate, they may make incorrect assumptions about rates at which demographics are likely to turn out). Additionally, undecided voters making up their minds at the very last minute break could disproportionately to one candidate or side. These things happen!

But if polls are consistently erring, over multiple cycles, in the same partisan direction, and often in the same states or regions, that may indicate a fundamental problem.

Part of the recent debate among election analysts is about whether that has actually happened — that is, in how we should interpret those last few cycles of poll results. Has there been a consistent overestimation of Democrats — meaning, a problem of pollsters reaching Trump-supporting Republicans? Or has it been a more mixed set of results from which people are over-reading patterns?

If you look at Senate polling of competitive contests from 2014 to 2020, and swing state presidential polling in 2016 and 2020, the pattern of bias seems quite plain: Polling underestimated Republicans far more often than Democrats in these contests, which stretch across several cycles at this point. Often, these errors were most pronounced in certain states or regions, such as Rust Belt states or very red states. So Cohn sees “warning signs” that recent polls may be overestimating Democrats in those same states, an “artifact of persistent and unaddressed biases in survey research.”

Silver takes a broader view, incorporating polling nationally, of governor’s races, and of off-year and special elections into his analysis, and concludes that the picture looks more mixed. He argues that polls have either been pretty close or even underestimated Democrats in various elections in 2017, 2021, and 2022 (particularly after the Dobbs decision). He views 2018 in particular as a mixed bag, not demonstrating a “systematic Democratic bias.” And he posits that perhaps “Republicans benefit from higher turnout only when Trump himself is on the ballot,” meaning that 2016 and 2020 might be the wrong elections to focus on when thinking about this year.

See also  New book reveals palace staff's nasty name for Meghan Markle

A closer look at 2018

I have a different interpretation of polls’ performance in 2018 than Silver, though. According to his numbers, polling averages underestimated Democrats by about 1 point on average in the House and in governor’s races, and there was no partisan bias in Senate polls on average that year.

But there’s a catch: The Senate map that year had an unusually large amount of contests in solidly blue states, none of which proved to be competitive. Democrats outperformed polls in nearly all of those contests.

Yet if we look at 2018’s actually competitive races — which that year were in purple and red states — most Democratic candidates underperformed their polls, and often by quite a lot.

The final margin was more than 3 points more unfavorable to the Democrat than FiveThirtyEight’s final polling averages in Florida, West Virginia, Michigan, Ohio, Tennessee, Missouri, and Indiana. There was only one competitive state — Nevada — in which the Democrat outperformed polls by more than 3 points.

So, for the purposes of someone trying to figure out which way the Senate would tip, the polls did functionally underestimate Republicans in 2018 too.

Here’s another caveat, though: 2022’s competitive Senate map does not look like 2018’s. That year, Democrats were defending 10 seats in states Trump won two years prior, including many deep red states (including North Dakota, Indiana, and Missouri, where some of the biggest polling errors were). 2014’s competitive map, another year where the polls significantly underestimated the GOP, was similarly red. But in 2022, Democrats’ top seats to defend or pick up are in pure purple states that Biden won narrowly: Georgia, Nevada, Arizona, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin.

The trick about trying to draw lessons from history is that nothing will ever be identical. Each situation is new and will have similarities and differences to things that happened in the past. A comparison necessitates choosing certain past events to examine, while omitting others. And the more past events you look at, the more conflicting evidence you’ll find.

Our goal this month

Now is not the time for paywalls. Now is the time to point out what’s hidden in plain sight (for instance, the hundreds of election deniers on ballots across the country), clearly explain the answers to voters’ questions, and give people the tools they need to be active participants in America’s democracy. Reader gifts help keep our well-sourced, research-driven explanatory journalism free for everyone. By the end of September, we’re aiming to add 5,000 new financial contributors to our community of Vox supporters. Will you help us reach our goal by making a gift today?

Get Xbox Gift Cards Free, Free $500 Gift Cards for Xbox One and Xbox Goving Away Free $5 Gift Cards through Message?
Free Fortnite V-bucks Generator and Fortnite V Bucks Redeem Code and K7n56u
Free Fortnite V-bucks Generator and V Bucks and Cjjv6p
Paysafe Code Free and Free Paysafe Card 
Free Xbox Gift Cards Youtube, Free Xbox Gift Cards without Human Verification and Free Xbox Gift Cards 2022 No Human Verification 
[9GR8R6] Cheap Switch Game Codes and Does Rite Aid Sell Paypal Cards
Free Tiktok Followers Generator and Tiktok++ Hack and Xtnrvr
PSN Free Gift Cards App and Free Gift Cards for PSN Store Walmart App
[LN1CVR] Free Eshop Credit and Redeem Eshop Code 
Free Fortnite V-bucks Generator and Promo Codes Fortnite and 1ijzw1
[OKGZGO] New on Nintendo Eshop and Australia Itunes Gift Card Codes
claim free money on cash app, how to make money for free on cash app and legit ways to get free money on cash app 
[6UHTEJ] Nintendo Store Code and Can You Gift Nintendo Eshop Games
Free Tiktok Followers Generator and Tiktok Real Time and W2rbch
Amazon PSN Gift Cards Codes Free and Free Gift Cards for PSN
3BXPI Free Paysafecards and Free Paysafecard Codes 2022
Free Tiktok Followers Generator and Tiktok Bumbum App and G5uzle
Get Free Xbox Gift Cards for Free, Xbox 360 Free Gift Cards and Xbox Live Gold Gift Cards Free
how to scam cash app and get free money, how to get free money from cash app and cash app 2022 free money
How to Get Free PSN Gift Cards and PSN Gift Cards Free 
L8W3Q Paysafe Online Buy and Coduri Paysafe 
Free Fortnite V-bucks Generator and Fnbucks
Free Fortnite V-bucks Generator and Free Redeem Codes for Fortnite and 7kueik
Free PSN Gift Cards PSN and Free Gift Cards for PSN and Gift Card Generator
Get Free Xbox Gift Cards, Xbox Gift Cards Free Codes and Free Xbox Gift Cards $100
easy ways to get free money on cash app, $100 free cash app money no human verification and who sends free money on cash app
Free Tiktok Followers Generator and Tiktok Follwers and M7el5l
PSN Free Gift Cards App and Free Gift Cards for PSN Store Walmart App
Free Tiktok Followers Generator and Bump App Tiktok and 1ln88o
Amazon PSN Gift Cards Codes Free and Free Gift Cards for PSN
Free Fortnite V-bucks Generator and Fortnite Vbucks Code and 16nea1
Free Fortnite V-bucks Generator and Free Fortnite Redeem Codes 2022 and 0uj5hg
Free Tiktok Followers Generator and Tiktok Followers Trial and Mwxvyv
[CLQJS9] Www Giftcards Eu and How to Redeem a Gift Card on Nintendo Switch
Free Tiktok Followers Generator and Buy Tiktok Views Paypal and Rqcsja
PSN \Gift Cards for Free and Free PSN Gift Cards in Pakistan
Free 100 Xbox Gift Cards, Free Xbox 100 Doller Gift Cards and How to Get Codes on Xbox One Gift Cards Free
Code Free Xbox Gift Cards, Real Xbox Gift Cards Free and Free Xbox Gift Cards No Surveys 2011
Free Xbox Gift Cards No Surveys or Offers 2022, Get Multiple Xbox Gift Cards Free and Get Free Xbox Live Gift Cards
Free Fortnite V-bucks Generator and Fortnite Pve Free Release Date and Xm0un3
Free Xbox Gift Cards No Surveys or Offers, Free Xbox Gift Cards Live Codes Android App Scam and Xbox Store Gift Cards for Free No Survey
Paysafecard Kostenlos 2022 and Paysafecard Sign up
Free Tiktok Followers Generator and Tiktok like Bot Free and Ze1mdp
By californianews_gkdgq8

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Related Posts